While district heating and cooling in the UK is finally gaining traction, thanks to a relatively stable policy environment, the sector’s growth is still sluggish. The nation’s reliance on gas boilers remains a significant hurdle to speeding the transition to greener heating solutions.
Article based on the original article by Sarah McArthur, published in Foresight Media on August 1, 2024
British consumers still need convincing of district heating benefits
The transition to renewable energy in the UK has taken on renewed urgency under the current government’s commitment to decarbonisation. District heating and cooling (DHC) networks could play a critical role in this shift by reducing reliance on fossil fuels, improving energy security, and stabilizing heating costs. However, DHC currently supplies only 2% of the UK’s heating needs—significantly lagging behind Northern European countries like Sweden and Denmark, where DHC accounts for up to 75% of heat demand.
The potential of DHC
The new UK government is actively promoting the energy transition, with DHC networks emerging as a promising solution. Unlike traditional fossil fuel-based systems, DHC networks are “heat-agnostic” and can adapt to various energy sources as they become available, from biomass and biofuels to excess wind and solar energy. This flexibility allows DHC to reduce emissions and manage costs efficiently.
In Denmark, for example, excess wind power is often absorbed by DHC networks via electric boilers, a strategy that could be replicated in Scotland, where wind energy is frequently curtailed. This approach offers the dual benefit of enhancing grid stability while also supporting the decarbonisation of heat.
Improving energy security
The UK is feeling the full effects of volatile global gas prices, especially since its own North Sea oil and gas reserves have diminished. Average gas and electricity prices in the UK have increased by 39% compared to the winter of 2021/22, and nearly half of UK households reported struggling to pay their energy bills in early 2024.
Heat networks provide a potential solution by insulating consumers from these price shocks. DHC allows for the use of domestically sourced renewable energy, such as wind and solar, to heat homes and businesses, reducing the UK’s dependence on international gas markets. According to industry experts, DHC could be the only viable solution for densely populated urban areas, where other technologies like heat pumps may be inefficient or impractical.
Challenges of retrofitting
Despite its potential, the UK faces significant challenges in scaling up DHC. Unlike Denmark and Sweden, which integrated DHC into their expanding cities, the UK must retrofit existing urban infrastructure, dismantling outdated gas grids in the process. This makes the deployment of DHC more complex and costly.
The UK also lags in regulatory frameworks and market mechanisms that support DHC expansion. Policies and regulations have been slow to adapt, though recent initiatives like the Heat Networks Act 2021 in Scotland and the Energy Bill 2023 in England and Wales are steps in the right direction. These laws aim to create zoning frameworks where heat networks are cost-effective and enforce obligations on building owners to assess their ability to connect to these networks.
Green shoots of progress
There are signs of progress, with substantial public and private investments driving momentum. From 2022 to 2028, the Green Heat Network Fund (GHNF) and the Heat Network Efficiency Scheme will provide over £1 billion in funding to support the development and improvement of heat networks in England, Wales, and Scotland.
Private companies like 1Energy plan to invest £1 billion in new heat networks over the next five years, while local authorities across the UK are beginning to explore and implement DHC systems. For instance, Bristol’s two existing heat networks are set to expand with a £475 million investment from Ameresco and Vattenfall UK, aiming to heat 12,000 homes by 2027.
Need for consumer trust
Despite these developments, many challenges remain, particularly in convincing consumers of DHC’s benefits. One key issue is price regulation. As DHC systems are natural monopolies, price transparency and regulation are essential to ensuring fair tariffs for consumers. The UK energy regulator Ofgem will take responsibility for overseeing heat networks starting in 2025, ensuring that consumers are protected regardless of whether the networks are publicly or privately owned.
Experts also emphasize the need to build trust among consumers, who may hesitate to switch to DHC if they perceive it as more expensive or less reliable than traditional heating methods. Ensuring competitive pricing, combined with transparent communication about the long-term benefits of DHC, will be critical in encouraging adoption.
The role of local authorities
Local authorities will also play a crucial role in DHC deployment, particularly in planning and securing anchor loads for the networks. However, after years of austerity, many local councils lack the expertise and resources to develop these systems. While some authorities have successfully implemented DHC schemes, much of this success is due to specific local conditions or the presence of knowledgeable civil servants.
To address this, the UK and Scottish governments are establishing centralised support agencies to help local councils navigate the complexities of heat network development. In Scotland, the Heat Network Support Unit has already been set up to assist in the early planning and implementation stages.
A race against time
While the groundwork has been laid for DHC in the UK, significant hurdles remain. Although private investment is ready to fund the expansion of heat networks, national and local authorities must quickly develop the necessary frameworks and expertise to ensure that these networks are deployed efficiently and equitably.
The growth of DHC in the UK is accelerating, but whether policy can keep pace with industry developments remains to be seen. As energy prices continue to rise and the demand for renewable energy grows, the coming years will be crucial in determining whether the UK can meet its ambitious goals for decarbonising heat.
📚 Curious to learn more?
You can find all our district energy news here.